featured
Is the Play-Off lottery still fair? Wembley hero Saša Ilić on persistence, promotion and penalty shootouts
Play-Off Final winning goalkeeper Ilić discusses the nature of one of football's most unique matches.
It’s 1998, and the greatest Play-Off Final of all time seems like it’s never going to end.
Charlton Athletic striker Clive Mendonca has bagged the first ever Play-Off final hat-trick against his boyhood club, Sunderland. His teammate Richard Rufus has scored his first ever senior goal. The only problem is that Addicks goalkeeper Saša Ilić, who had kept nine clean sheets in a row leading up to the final, has also conceded four.
Both goalkeepers have had just as little luck in the ensuing penalty shootout. 13 penalties have been taken, and 13 penalties have been scored. So, as Sunderland’s Michael Gray steps forward for yet another do-or-die spot-kick, Ilić decides to take a new approach.
He decides to leave it up to chance.
“Towards the end of the penalty shootout, you get sort of frustrated,” he tells Goalkeeper.com. “You’re going one way, the ball’s going the other way. It just doesn’t seem like it’s going to come to an end. And I saw this coin on the pitch on the right side of the post.
“So I sort of flicked it, and I’m like ‘Okay, because I’m not having any luck saving these penalties, if it’s on heads I’ll dive to my left, if it’s tails I’ll dive to my right.’ Fortunately, it went on heads!”
One dive later and Charlton were going to the Premier League.
Much like the coin, it was a series of coincidences which meant that Ilić had even made it to Wembley in the first place. As a Serbian-Australian living in the former Yugoslavia during the bloody civil war in 1996, Ilić visited his sisters in London. On the last night before he was due to return to Belgrade, he got chatting to Sheffield United midfielder-turned-marketing-manager Mike Trusson at football-themed restaurant Football Football.
Within a few months, Ilić had moved permanently to London and was playing seventh-tier football for Trusson’s former club St. Leonards Stamcroft. A year later, having impressed scouts from a number of teams, he was training at Charlton.
“I didn’t really have much money,” he remembers. “My sisters would lend me some money to jump on the train from where they were living in Putney. So I had to commute from Putney all the way to New Eltham, like a two-and-a-half-hour trip. And I did that with a huge smile on my face!”
His excellent form in training – coupled with an injury to Mike Salmon – meant that, on February 25th, 1998, Ilić made his Charlton debut in a 2-1 win at Stoke. Exactly three months and 12 clean sheets later, his astonishing rise had taken him all the way to Wembley.
“It was like I literally fell from the sky into Charlton,” he says. “I didn’t understand the hype of all of it, because I was just sort of thrown into it. It was a case for me where [the Play-Off Final] was just like any other game, and you approached it like any other game. But on the day we travelled to Wembley, we were greeted by 20,000, 30,000 Sunderland fans.
“And we got this huge roar – people showing their middle finger, saying all sorts of profanity towards us. And that’s when it kicked in, the importance of the actual game. And obviously, going to the changing room, walking out on the pitch, it was just like a space shuttle in my eyes.”
Three hours later Ilić had gone down in history as the man who decided one of the greatest Play-Off Finals of all time. Fast forward 28 years and, after a long career in England, Ilić now lives in Montenegro with his wife and two sons.
The Play-Offs themselves, meanwhile, are now 40 years old, and have arguably never been under more scrutiny. In each of the last two seasons, Championship teams have hit the 90-point mark and still not gone up. In the National League, the ever-more popular '3UP' campaign gathered more steam this season as Rochdale amassed 106 points and still needed to scrape a Play-Off final win on penalties to ascend to League Two.
From 2026/27, the Championship Play-Offs will expand from four to six teams.
Questions have been asked about whether the Play-Offs remain the fairest way of deciding promotion. Ilić, though – perhaps unsurprisingly – remains resolute that they are.
“That’s part and parcel of the excitement about football where you’re giving an underdog a chance to grab that trophy,” he says. “I think that’s what makes football super exciting. If you’ve done well throughout the season and you’ve accumulated 20 or 30 points more, on paper you should be winning these games.
“But, you know, if you fail at the last hurdle, you’re not ready for it. You’re not ready for it, because you’re going to have a lot more challenging situations in the Premiership or the league above you, if you can’t handle the Play-Off. So, in some ways, it’s a good way to maybe see mentally where these players are.”
Ilić is also an expert on what those games can do for a player’s legacy.
“A footballer’s career is quite a short career. I think it’s very difficult, even when you’re a professional footballer, to exceed your level. But these sorts of situations can make a player excel quickly, can give a player a bit more recognition if they do particularly well in this one game. Whether that’s a good thing or a bad thing, I don’t know. I just know I’m one of those people that benefitted from that,” he says.
“It creates legends, it creates an aura, it creates something for people to talk about.”
This year’s Championship Play-Off final has thrown up one of the biggest talking points of all: the ‘spygate’ scandal. But Ilić is not convinced that Southampton should be expelled for their alleged misconduct.
“That’s all absurd. I think it’s more paper talk than anything else. If you’ve lost because of a couple of photographs, mate, then… no,” he laughs.
In an age when preparations for the Play-Offs are so intense that they can include spying on the other team, it seems unlikely that either Daniel Peretz or Ivor Pandur would have wanted to leave their fate up to the toss of a coin.
For Pandur at least, he'll be hoping and praying that his numbers are drawn in this weekend's Play-Off lottery.